| Platinum | Mamma Maria's Italian Eatery |
| Gold | Quo Vadis Pizzeria |
| Silver | Pie-Zano's Authentic Italian Pizza |
| Bronze | Andy's Place |
| Top Pick | Chilled Cork |
| Top Pick | Italian Stallion Wood Fire Pizza |
| Top Pick | Konstantinos Pizza and Wings |
| Top Pick | Oven 360 Chatham |