| Platinum | Sweet C's Cookie Creation |
| Gold | Real Food Kitchen and Bake Shop |
| Silver | Big Ricky's Little Bake Shoppe |
| Bronze | Jen's Keto Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Heidi's Eats and Sweets |
| Top Pick | Homebaked Kitchen Company |
| Top Pick | Lisa Roberts Cakes |
| Top Pick | Maple City Bakery |
| Top Pick | Small Town Cakes |
| Top Pick | Union Block Bakery |