| Platinum | Cone and Shake Shop |
| Gold | Riverside Ice Cream |
| Silver | Bowl of Cream |
| Bronze | Frostbites |
| Top Pick | Ice Cream Dreams |
| Top Pick | Marble Slab |
| Top Pick | Scoops Tilbury |
| Top Pick | Sugared Spoon |
| Top Pick | The Sugar Shack |
| Top Pick | Yecks The Other Place |
| Big Ricky's Little Bake Shoppe |
